|
AUSTIN, Texas -- On one of those
television gong shows that passes for journalism, the panelists used to have
to pick an Outrage of the Week. Then, each performer would wax indignant
about his or choice for 60 seconds or so. If someone asked me to name the
Outrage of the Week about now, I'd have a coronary. How could anyone
possibly choose?
I suppose the frontrunner is the anti-torture amendment. Sen. John McCain
proposed an amendment to the military appropriations bill that would
prohibit "cruel, inhuman or degrading" treatment of prisoners in the custody
of the U.S. military.
This may strike you as a "goes without saying" proposition -- the amendment
passed the Senate 90 to nine. The United States has been signing
anti-torture treaties under Democrats and Republicans for at least 50 years.
But the Bush administration actually managed to find some weasel words to
create a loophole in this longstanding commitment to civilized behavior.
According to the Bushies, if the United States is holding a prisoner on
foreign soil, our soldiers can still subject him or her to cruel, inhuman
and degrading treatment -- the very forms of torture used by the soldiers
who were later prosecuted for their conduct at Abu Ghraib. Does this make
any sense, moral or common?
So deeply does President Bush feel our country, despite all its treaty
commitments, has a right to torture that he has threatened to veto the bill
if it passes. This would the first time in five years he has ever vetoed
anything. Think about it: Five years of stupefying pork, ideological
nonsense, dumb administrative ideas, fiscal idiocy, misbegotten energy
programs -- and the first thing the man vetoes is a bill to pay our soldiers
because it carries an amendment saying, once again, that this country does
not torture prisoners.
This is the United States of America. It is our country, not George W.
Bush's personal property. The United States of America still stands for the
rights of man, for freedom, dignity and justice. We do not torture helpless
prisoners. Our soldiers are not the SS, not the North Vietnamese who
tortured McCain and others for years on end, not bestial Argentinean
fascists, not the Khmer Rouge.
Remember, we invaded Iraq because Saddam Hussein was such a horrible brute
that he tortured people. This is beyond disgusting. The House Republicans,
which have no shame, will try to weaken McCain's amendment. They need to
hear from decent Republicans all over this country. Don't leave this hideous
stain on your party's name. This is NOT what America stands for. We've had
more loathsome and more dangerous enemies than Al-Qaida and managed to
defeat them without resorting to torture.
And leading the charge in the House will be Tom DeLay, that pillar of moral
rectitude and Christian mercy. Wait a minute: Didn't DeLay have to step down
from his leadership position after he got indicted? Well, yes, but some
step-downs are more down than others. There was The Hammer in full glory
last Friday, twisting arms and working the floor on behalf of a real cutie
of a bill to benefit the oil companies.
Even Republicans revolted. As Rep. Sherwood Boehlert said, "We are enriching
people, but we are not doing anything to give the little guy a break." This
bill was so awful the leadership had to hold the vote open for 40 minutes, a
clear violation of House rules -- there's a five-minute limit on votes of
this kind -- while the Republican leaders roamed the floor, cajoling,
bullying and threatening.
I have become inured to Bush's idea of foreign policy, which is to tell the
rest of the world, "Kiss my behind." But the policy does result in some
lovely ironies. On Friday, Mohamed ElBaradei, the highly respected head of
the United Nation's International Atomic Energy Agency, won the Nobel Peace
Prize. Quite apart from whether you support George Bush or not, ElBaradei
and the IAEA deserve the honor -- they have been both diligent and
effective.
ElBaradei was right when he repeatedly warned the Bush administration Iraq
did not have any weapons of mass destruction and has said the day the United
States invaded "was the saddest in my life."
But you know our boy George: not for him the gracious, "Gee, you were right,
and we wrong after all." Nope, after ElBaradei was proved right, Bush tried
to have him fired. And the man in charge of carrying out the campaign to
have the guy fired for being right? John Bolton, now our ambassador to the
United Nations.
|